What Are the Four Horsemen?
Four decades of research from the "Love Lab"
Dr. John Gottman has spent over 40 years studying couples at the University of Washington's "Love Lab," observing thousands of relationships through their most vulnerable moments. His most significant finding: he can predict whether a couple will divorce with 93% accuracy by identifying four destructive communication patterns he calls the "Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse."
These aren't dramatic, relationship-ending fights. They're subtle, everyday patterns that slowly erode the foundation of fondness and admiration between partners. The damage happens not in explosive arguments but in the thousand small moments where criticism replaces curiosity, contempt replaces compassion, defensiveness replaces openness, and stonewalling replaces engagement.
The good news: Gottman also identified specific antidotes for each horseman. Relationships aren't doomed by conflict — they're doomed by how couples handle conflict. Understanding these patterns is the first step toward replacing them with healthier alternatives. If you're wondering how your connection handles conflict, a relationship tarot reading can offer additional perspective alongside these research-backed insights.
The Four Horsemen — Explained
Each horseman represents a specific type of relational attack or defense that, if left unchecked, systematically erodes trust and connection.
Criticism
Attacking your partner's character rather than addressing a specific behavior.
Example: "You are so selfish; you never think of anyone but yourself" instead of "I'm upset that the dishes weren't done."
Criticism often starts with "you always" or "you never." It globalizes a complaint into a character indictment. Over time, the criticized partner feels fundamentally flawed rather than being asked to change a behavior.
Antidote: Gentle Start-Up — Use "I" statements to express a feeling about a specific behavior and state a positive need. "I feel overwhelmed when the kitchen is messy. Could we tackle it together tonight?"
Contempt
#1 Divorce PredictorCommunicating from a position of moral superiority through sarcasm, mockery, eye-rolling, or sneering.
Example: "Oh, you forgot to pay the bill? What a surprise. You can't even handle basic adult responsibilities."
Contempt is fueled by long-simmering negative thoughts about your partner. It conveys disgust and disrespect. Research shows contempt not only destroys relationships but impairs the recipient's immune system, increasing susceptibility to infectious illness.
Antidote: Culture of Appreciation — Regularly express gratitude and focus on your partner's positive qualities. Build a habit of scanning for what they do right instead of cataloguing what they do wrong.
Defensiveness
Shifting blame or playing the innocent victim in response to a perceived attack.
Example: "It's not my fault we're late; you're the one who takes forever to get ready."
Defensiveness is typically a response to criticism. The defensive partner refuses to accept any responsibility, which escalates conflict and prevents resolution. It communicates "the problem isn't me, it's you."
Antidote: Taking Responsibility — Accept even a small portion of the blame to de-escalate. "You're right, I should have reminded you about the time. I can see how that was frustrating."
Stonewalling
Withdrawing from the interaction entirely — shutting down, becoming unresponsive, or physically leaving.
Example: Going silent mid-argument, staring at a phone, walking out of the room without explanation, or giving one-word responses.
About 85% of stonewallers are men. Stonewalling is often a byproduct of physiological "flooding" — when the heart rate exceeds 100 BPM, the fight-or-flight response makes rational conversation impossible. The stonewaller isn't being stubborn; their nervous system has taken over.
Antidote: Physiological Self-Soothing — Take a structured 20-minute break to allow heart rate and cortisol levels to return to baseline. Tell your partner: "I need 20 minutes to calm down, then I'll come back and we'll continue."
The Antidotes at a Glance
Every horseman has a research-backed antidote. The goal isn't to eliminate conflict — it's to manage it with skill.
The Magic Ratio: 5 Positive Interactions to Every 1 Negative
The mathematical formula for relationship stability
Gottman's research revealed a precise mathematical threshold that separates stable relationships from unstable ones. Happy couples maintain a ratio of at least 5 positive interactions for every 1 negative interaction during conflict. Couples heading for divorce typically have a ratio closer to 0.8:1 — nearly equal negative and positive.
What Counts as Positive?
- +Showing genuine interest in their day
- +Expressing affection and appreciation
- +Using humor to de-escalate tension
- +Active listening without interrupting
- +Offering empathy and validation
- +Making successful repair attempts
Repair Attempts: The Secret Weapon
Repair attempts are efforts to de-escalate tension during conflict — a touch on the arm, a joke, saying "I'm sorry, let me try again," or even making a silly face. Gottman found that the success or failure of repair attempts is one of the primary factors that determines whether a couple will make it.
In distressed relationships, repair attempts go unnoticed or are rejected because negative sentiment override has taken hold — partners interpret even neutral actions as negative. If you're wondering about the health of your relationship dynamics, an are we compatible tarot reading can offer an additional lens.
Get Weekly Love Guidance
Receive love tarot insights and relationship wisdom in your inbox.
How Your Attachment Style Triggers the Four Horsemen
Why some couples fall into these patterns more easily
Your attachment style — shaped in early childhood and carried into adult relationships — predicts which horsemen you're most likely to deploy during conflict. Understanding this connection is the first step toward breaking the pattern.
Anxious Attachment → Criticism
Anxiously attached individuals use criticism as a "protest behavior" — escalating complaints to force engagement from a withdrawing partner. The underlying message isn't "you're terrible" but "please see me, please respond." The intensity of the criticism matches the intensity of the fear of abandonment driving it.
Avoidant Attachment → Stonewalling
Avoidantly attached individuals use stonewalling as a "deactivating strategy." When emotional intensity threatens their sense of autonomy, they shut down to protect themselves. Despite appearing calm, research shows their cortisol levels and heart rates are often as elevated as their anxious partner's — they're just processing internally rather than externally.
Disorganised Attachment → All Four
Disorganised attachment — often rooted in early trauma — can cycle through all four horsemen in rapid succession. One moment criticising, then contemptuous, then defensive, then completely shut down. The unpredictability itself becomes a source of distress for both partners, making repair attempts difficult to land.
Secure Attachment → Repair Attempts Work
Securely attached individuals aren't immune to the four horsemen, but they're much better at catching them early and deploying repair attempts successfully. They can say "I'm sorry, I just criticised you" and course-correct mid-conversation, maintaining the 5:1 positive ratio even during difficult discussions.
When Your Body Takes Over: Understanding Flooding
The physiological hijack behind stonewalling
Flooding is the physiological state that triggers stonewalling. When conflict escalates, the body's alarm system activates: heart rate climbs above 100 BPM, cortisol floods the bloodstream, and the prefrontal cortex — responsible for rational thought, empathy, and problem-solving — goes offline. You're no longer arguing with your partner; your nervous system is fighting for survival.
What Happens During Flooding
- •Heart rate exceeds 100 BPM — the threshold where rational conversation becomes impossible
- •Cortisol spike — stress hormones prepare the body for fight or flight, not nuanced discussion
- •Tunnel vision and hearing — you literally cannot process your partner's words accurately
- •85% of stonewallers are men — male cardiovascular systems tend to reach flooding faster and recover slower
The Self-Soothing Protocol
When you notice flooding starting, call a structured break — not a storming-off. The protocol: tell your partner you need exactly 20 minutes (the minimum time for physiological recovery). During those 20 minutes, avoid rehearsing the argument or stoking your grievances. Instead, do something genuinely calming: walk, breathe deeply, listen to music, or read. Return when your body has settled, and re-engage with the conversation.
If you're navigating intense emotions in your relationship and looking for additional guidance, a relationship clarity tarot reading may help you process what you're feeling.
Signs the Four Horsemen Have Taken Hold
The escalation pattern that predicts relationship collapse
The four horsemen don't typically arrive all at once. They follow a predictable escalation: criticism opens the door, which invites contempt as negativity compounds. Contempt triggers defensiveness as the attacked partner protects themselves, and chronic defensiveness eventually leads to stonewalling as one or both partners give up on being heard.
Arguments start with "you always" or "you never" instead of specific concerns
Eye-rolling, sarcasm, or mockery has become a regular response during disagreements
Neither partner can accept even partial responsibility during conflict
One partner physically or emotionally withdraws during difficult conversations
Repair attempts (humor, touch, apology) are ignored or rejected
You find yourself keeping a mental tally of your partner's failures
Conversations feel like a courtroom — building cases rather than seeking understanding
You or your partner have stopped bringing up concerns because "nothing will change"
Positive interactions have become rare — you coexist more than you connect
You feel contempt (disgust, superiority) rather than frustration when your partner makes mistakes
If you recognize several of these patterns, explore where your relationship stands with a relationship tarot reading.
Can a Relationship Survive the Four Horsemen?
Yes — if you catch it early and commit to change
Gottman's research isn't just diagnostic — it's hopeful. The same research that identified the four horsemen also identified the precise behaviors that successful couples use to maintain lasting love. His Sound Relationship House model outlines seven levels of a healthy partnership, from building "Love Maps" (knowing each other's inner world) to creating shared meaning and purpose.
When Recovery Is Likely
- •Both partners acknowledge the patterns and want to change
- •Contempt hasn't become the dominant communication style
- •There's still a foundation of fondness and admiration underneath
- •Willingness to seek professional help (Gottman Method Therapy)
When Professional Help Is Critical
- •Contempt has become the default response to your partner
- •One partner has mentally "checked out" of the relationship
- •Repair attempts consistently fail or aren't even attempted
- •The relationship involves emotional, verbal, or physical abuse
The Foundation: Trust and Commitment
At the base of Gottman's Sound Relationship House sits trust and commitment — the belief that your partner has your best interests at heart and is in this for the long haul. When this foundation is solid, the four horsemen have less power. When it's cracked, even minor disagreements can feel catastrophic. Rebuilding trust starts with small, consistent actions — showing up, following through, choosing your partner over your ego.
Four Horsemen FAQ
Common questions about Gottman's relationship research
What are the four horsemen in a relationship?
Which horseman is the strongest predictor of divorce?
Can contempt be fixed in a relationship?
What is stonewalling and why do men do it more?
What is the Gottman 5:1 ratio?
How do I stop criticising my partner?
What is the difference between criticism and a complaint?
How do attachment styles relate to the four horsemen?
When should you seek couples therapy?
Is it too late if contempt is present?
Still have questions? We're here to help!
Contact Support →Try Our Free Spiritual Calculators
Get deeper insights with our interactive tools
Explore More Tarot Readings
Discover different ways to gain insight and guidance through our free tarot card readings